New book challenges the view of clinical depression as a single uniform disorder
The authors of a new book analyse mental health from an evolutionary perspective, which challenges the understanding of clinical depression as a single, uniform disorder. The authors identify twelve pathways that can lead to depression. An evolutionary perspective on mental health suggests that treatment should also address causes of depression and not just the symptoms.
According to evolutionary behavioural scientists Markus J. Rantala from the University of Turku in Finland and Severi Luoto from the University of Auckland in New Zealand, people with the same diagnosis of depression can experience strikingly different symptoms. Some lose their appetite, while others overeat. Some struggle with insomnia, while others sleep excessively. Psychomotor activity may either slow down or become unusually restless. For the researchers, this diversity raises a fundamental question: does depression represent a single disorder or several distinct conditions, which can sometimes share some of the same symptoms?
Their new book titled Depression: Evolution, Biology, and Treatments, published by Cambridge University Press in October 2026, provides a broad overview of the latest research on the causes, consequences, and treatments of depression, with a deep view on its evolutionary origins.
“Clinical depression refers to depression that meets the diagnostic criteria. In our book, we use the term ‘clinical depression’ to refer to depression that meets the diagnostic criteria for major depressive disorder,” says Markus J. Rantala.
The authors argue that depression may be better understood as a group of different conditions that arise from different biological mechanisms and life circumstances rather than as a single disorder.
The book presents twelve potential pathways to clinical depression
Rantala and Luoto propose that a range of different factors can cause depression. They have identified twelve broad pathways to clinical depression, such as infection and long-term stress. The authors state that it is possible for several factors to operate at the same time or in succession, and that different pathways to clinical depression may involve different biological mechanisms, which in turn can cause different symptom profiles.
The authors argue that natural selection has shaped the human mood system to be responsive to external factors because such responses were adaptive in the evolutionary history of primates and other life forms. However, this does not necessarily mean that mood responses remain adaptive today.
“Human lifestyles have changed dramatically, yet the human mind is still largely shaped by psychobehavioural adaptations that evolved under our ancestral conditions. As a result, responses that once had clear functions may now become too intense or prolonged. They can produce combinations of depressive symptoms that no longer help resolve the problems that triggered them,” says Rantala.
“One reason why depression has become common in modern Western societies is that contemporary western lifestyles promote chronic stress and low-grade systemic inflammation,” says Severi Luoto and continues: “As chronic stress and inflammation influence mood and behaviour, they can intensify and prolong emotional responses to adverse life events, such as bereavement or relationship breakdown, turning initially adaptive mood changes into persistent depressive states.”
Researchers: “treatment should address causes, not just symptoms”
The authors state that as low-grade systemic inflammation and long-term stress appear to play an important role in the development and persistence of some cases of depression, lifestyle interventions that address the biological systems mediating these processes could help both prevent and alleviate depressive symptoms in such cases.
The book reviews the latest research on the connection between lifestyle and mental health, including the most promising treatments. Regular physical activity, time spent in nature, healthy nutrition, selected nutritional supplements, and stress-management techniques constitute potential approaches to preventing and alleviating depression.
The authors do not, in general, dispute the importance of antidepressants in the treatment of depression, but they point out that these medications are primarily aimed at treating the symptoms of depression.
“Effective treatment requires understanding not only what symptoms a person has, and not just pharmacologically treating those symptoms, but also why that person became depressed in the first place, and seeking to address the underlying causes,” the authors encourage.
For more information, please contact:
Markus J. Rantala
University of Turku
markus.rantala@utu.fi
+358503697417
Severi Luoto
University of Auckland
tluo230@aucklanduni.ac.nz
+64 22 439 7351